horse in a pasture surrounded by mountains

5 Sweet Shops You Need to Try at The Island in Pigeon Forge

big rock candy kitchen
October 20, 2025

If you have a sweet tooth, there is no better destination in the Smoky Mountains than The Island in Pigeon Forge! This popular entertainment complex not only features amusement rides, restaurants, and unique shopping experiences, but also a variety of candy stores with all kinds of tempting goodies! Whether you’re craving homemade fudge, cookies, or saltwater taffy, you’re sure to find it here! Here are 5 sweet shops that you need to try at The Island in Pigeon Forge:

1. Byrd’s Famous Cookies

Byrds Famous Cookies The Island Pigeon Forge

Byrd’s Famous Cookies is your one-stop shop for cookie fans, as the iconic Byrd Cookie Company has been serving up the same delicious cookie recipes since 1924! Step up to the Cookie Bar for free samples of your favorite flavors, or perhaps taste a different one to discover a new favorite! The store also features a great selection of sweet treats and specialty pantry items, so take something special home with you or purchase a gift for a loved one!

2. Big Rock Candy Kitchen

While visiting The Island in Pigeon Forge, you won’t want to miss the Big Rock Candy Kitchen! This awesome shop features the best candies in the Smokies, including homemade sweets and treats made from scratch! While browsing through the store, some of the tasty items you’ll find include salt water taffy, creamy fudge, crisp caramel apples, gourmet popcorn, and gelato! The only thing better than the candy is the friendly staff, so don’t be shy to ask for a free sample!

3. The Fudgery

The Fudgery Island Pigeon Forge

Another one of the Pigeon Forge sweet shops that you need to try at The Island is The Fudgery! This isn’t just a run-of-the-mill fudge shop, as the company has been offering delectable fudge products since 1980 and is getting even better with time! The fudge is made right in front of your eyes, and you can pick up fudge by the pound in 12 different options, ranging from rocky road and chocolate peanut butter to maple nut and extraordinary chocolate!

4. Kermit’s Key Lime Pie Shop

You can enjoy a taste of the Florida Keys right here in the Smokies with Kermit’s Key Lime Shop! This store is one of just a lucky few that are located outside of Key West, so take advantage of the unique opportunity to enjoy a slice of authentic key lime pie! Kermit’s Key Lime Shop also offers a variety of other key-lime-inspired treats, including key lime pie bars dipped in delicious chocolate, cookies, candies, and more!

5. Sweet!

candy shop pigeon forge

Candy lovers will have a blast at Sweet!, where you’ll find 2,500 square feet filled wall-to-wall with every kind of candy you can imagine! As soon as you walk through the door, you’ll be greeted with the delightful scent of sugary goodness and feel like you have just entered a life-size game board of CandyLand! From giant oversized jaw breakers to cereal box-sized Nerds, the store features anything you could ever need to fill your sugar craving!

These sweet shops are just the beginning of what to see and do at this iconic entertainment complex! Read more about some of the unique attractions at The Island in Pigeon Forge you must experience with your family!

Wears Valley View
June 26, 2020
Top 3 Restaurants in Wears Valley
woman walking dog
July 25, 2024
3 Great Places to Walk Your Dog Near Our Pet-Friendly Cabin Rentals in Pigeon Forge
Ripley's Haunted Adventure in Gatlinburg TN
September 29, 2025
3 Spooktacular Haunted Houses in Gatlinburg and Pigeon Forge to Experience This Halloween
winter in the smoky mountains
November 27, 2023
4 Things to Do This Winter in the Smoky Mountains
expand_less